So what's the other project that has occupied many of my summer evenings? Well, again, it's another old flame, but this time instead of boltguns and chainswords, its back to muskets and shakos. Napoleonics - 'The Beautiful Game' - remains my first miniature wargames love and for me it's experienced a bit of a renaissance with the release of Dan Brown's excellent 'General d'Armee' (GdA). The rules are quite 'crunchy' and somewhat overwrought in some spots, but on the whole they're pretty darn good and, for me, they manage to hit most of the sweet spots for a battalion-level set of instructions. The most important result from this resurgent interest is that it's driven me to get more Napoleonic games on the tabletop.
After a few recent games I came to the conclusion that I wanted to try playing this level of game in a figure scale smaller than 28mm. Don't get me wrong, I love all the colour and pageantry of 28mm Napoleonics, BUT the size of the units often constrains how much can be reasonably put on a normal tabletop. We typically game on an 8'x5' playing surface, and, allowing for room for flanks and a few bits of interesting terrain this means that we hit the limit at around 15 units per side. In Napoleonic terms that's around two to three brigades - a nice little game, but still fairly limited in scope. So, I really wanted the ability to do larger divisional-level games while still having room for the units to 'breathe'.
With all this in mind, I played around with the idea of expanding my recently repatriated 15mm collection (thanks Greg!). I even retouched/rebased a few units to see how they'd look - not bad, but I would need significantly more units, meaning lots of figures and heaps of painting. Definitely possible, but I needed to think on this more before pulling the trigger. Then, one afternoon I found myself looking through our display cabinets and came across my proof-of-concept 3mm ACW units that I did-up a few years back. I was reminded by how neat the 1:1 arrangement looked and wondered if I could 3D print something similar for Napoleonics, say in 2mm. I then remembered an online conversation I had with Zach, the talented creator of Forward March Studios about his 2mm range of figures. Well, it turns out that Zach is now offering his entire library of 3D print files for a very reasonable price. Inspired by this, I duly plunked down for the series of designs and began the process of test printing and plotting possible unit layouts.
After playing around with the raw printed models I quickly came to the conclusion that due to the relative ease of printing, assembly and painting, I wanted to create units which were more like boardgame playing pieces, composed of one base highlighting a specific formation. For example, a unit in line formation would be a single base with the battalion arrayed in line, whereas if it changed into column, or square, it would be swapped-out for a base reflecting those particular formations. This would be quite different the common multi-base approach, where players switch around their component unit bases to mimic the formations they need. Ok, why do this? Well, the thing that really excited me about this scale was its ability to convey how these formations would really look in relation to one another.
In this scale, the British 2-rank line looks realistically thin and elongated when compared to the bulkier 3-rank lines used by the French (and most continental armies). In looking at the British line, one can see how many French commanders would have thought that its apparent fragility would be susceptible to mass column attacks - not so much as it turned out.
Cavalry formations look great in this scale as well as the massed units really help emphasize the space that was required to properly maneuver these large groups of horsemen.
One formation that I especially enjoyed working on was the artillery batteries. Quite understandably due to cost and space considerations, artillery in most tabletop collections rarely illustrate the depth gun batteries would absorb, what with their limbers, ammunition caissons and support wagons. But doing this in 2mm it's an absolute doodle.
Note: for the artillery I broke my own rule by having them arrayed on multiple bases as I wanted to allow segments to be removed in order to allow other formations to park or move through it, something that was commonly done on the battlefield.
So, with a bit of head scratching and eraser nibbling I came up with a series of base shapes that could reflect the various formations commonly used during the period. I estimated I wanted around 30 battalions of infantry each for the French, Austrian, Prussian British and Russians, with a half dozen batteries and around 10 regiments of cavalry as supports. I reasoned that this 'recipe' would give me enough units to reflect a good sized corps per side and not overstress a modest sized table.
After I decided on my basing recipe, my good friend Byron over at Northern Lights Terrain cut me up a schwack of MDF bases to start the process.
Eagle-eyed readers with 15mm collections will see that that frontage of my units are probably not that far off from their own - it's really in the depth that the this scale really differentiates itself.
Is this in true 1:1 scale? No, but its very close. I estimate that these formations are roughly at 1: 1.3 ratio. Not bad!
The Process
The assembly and painting of these bases is a fairly straightforward affair - its definitely more of an assembly line approach than working with larger scales.
I find one of the tricks to tackling small scale projects is getting the basing and colour pallet right. My colour choices I'll talk about below, as to the bases, personally, I like them fairly thick (3mm) as it gives something to grip onto. I also like my bases with rounded corners as it gives the finished stands an almost chit/playing piece look about them. Horses for courses though!
The 3D prints I used for this project makes it very easy to organize and glue down the formations onto the bases, you just mix and match figure strips to the formation you want to do.
This unit will be a standard-sized French battalion, in line formation, five companies wide (the sixth company is assumed to be detached on skirmishing duties).
After the component pieces have been glued down, I apply a layer of fine sand over thinned down PVA on the base. I leave out a small corner section for the unit label and I glue down a steel shim for magnetized markers (more on that later).
Once the sand dries, I prime the base dark brown, and then apply an overspray of grey to help 'lift' lighter colours used later in the process. The groundwork is then painted a chocolate brown, drybrushed up with a mid and light browns and finally ending in a light khaki dusting. I just use cheap craft paint for all this work.
Yes, the base looks a bit wierd at this point, but the next step will set things to right. The base is given several coats of green emulsion from Woodland Scenics. A great product as I find it gives a very nice semi-opaque green effect to the groundwork.
Next is painting the figures themselves. Because of the extremely small scale, I typically use very bright (and very unhistorical) colours so they're easier to see on the tabletop. I simply paint the top half in the 'national' tunic colour - in this case a fairly vibrant blue for the French. I then paint an off-white strip along the bottom and highlight to indicate their trousers.
The light blue is then inked (or washed) with a darker shade. This will sink into the recesses and temporarily darken the overall tone. For the French I use Liquitex Prussian Blue ink (yeah, go figure).
I then highlight with the original colour (light blue in this case) with a few additional spots further lifted with some white mixed in. This gives the figures a bit more depth and aids in their overall visibility.
In order to make the figures better stand out on the base, I outline the formation with a dark brown mixed with a touch of black to create a shadow effect.
Usually the flags are the most fiddly part of the process, but I think the extra time invested really finishes off the base nicely. The French tricolour is fairly easy to do, whereas the British Union Jack can be a bit of a bear!
Aaand that's it for painting the figures. Yes, its very, VERY basic, but I've found that less is more when working with these smaller scales - if you try to paint too much detail it can often muddy the overall effect.
Now, we're almost done: The bases are given a very light scatter of fine flock over thinned PVA. Not too much though, just an impression, going heavy on the flock can often overwhelm the figures.
Finally I touch up the base edge with dark brown, affix a unit label at the bottom corner and magnetize the bottom for safe transport. Done!
I can usually get around 4-6 bases done during an evening's sitting, so roughly a brigade. In preparations for our first game I managed to get 20 battalions of infantry, 4 cavalry regiments and 2 artillery batteries done in around 2 weeks of work - I certainly couldn't have done that in 28mm!
Status Markers
I like using roster sheets to keep tabletop clutter to a minimum and for this project I wanted to take it further by having that ability to denote status right on top of the unit. For example, in GDA units can endure around 8-15 points of damage before breaking. I equated this to three levels/stages of attrition which a unit can be marked: blue for light damage, yellow for medium and red for critical. This way opposing players don't have perfect intelligence on precisely how knocked about an enemy unit is.
So to do this I purchased a pack of magnetic map 'pins' and then spray painted them in the three status colours. I keep them affixed to a thin steel sheet handy for the players to pull from.
During games we simply pick off the markers we need from the steel sheet and place them on the steel square located on the bottom left of each unit. This provides a relatively minimalist approach to marking unit status without having to use dice, counters, etc.
Storage
Storage is frequently a struggle for many miniature gamers as there just doesn't seem to be enough room to squirrel away all the shiny things we acquire. A great aspect of collecting microscale armies is that their storage and transport is SOOOO much easier than dealing with larger scales.
For this project I found that I could use inexpensive photo scrapbooking containers sourced from one of our local big box craft stores.
The larger containers can carry two of the thinner cases. I've estimated that each nationality could fit in four of the smaller cases, all nestled in two of the larger containers. Since they were available in multiple colours I snagged a pair for most of the nations' livery, red for British, light blue for French, white for Austrians/Spanish, and dark blue for Prussians. I just need to find a set of green cases for the Russians...
This entire project, encompassing five national armies, will fit in 10 cases. This makes it not only very compact to store, but is also fairly straightforward to select, transport and use during games.
____________________________
Okay, <phew> there you have it. A VERY long post (sorry about that!) of me describing how I spent a good portion of my summer evenings. A bit mental, but good fun.
I plan to do a few more updates on this project in order to cover terrain and a few oddball formations/units. Also, keep an eye out for a Peninsular War scenario that we've developed using these figures; that will be coming up soon as well.
Thanks for dropping in folks. Have a great week!
Next up: Sisters of Battle!
Here is a selection of 2mm models from Forward March. From front to back, a 2-flag infantry stand, a squadron of cavalry a round command stand, a load of windmills and a row of German themed houses. |
After playing around with the raw printed models I quickly came to the conclusion that due to the relative ease of printing, assembly and painting, I wanted to create units which were more like boardgame playing pieces, composed of one base highlighting a specific formation. For example, a unit in line formation would be a single base with the battalion arrayed in line, whereas if it changed into column, or square, it would be swapped-out for a base reflecting those particular formations. This would be quite different the common multi-base approach, where players switch around their component unit bases to mimic the formations they need. Ok, why do this? Well, the thing that really excited me about this scale was its ability to convey how these formations would really look in relation to one another.
In this scale, the British 2-rank line looks realistically thin and elongated when compared to the bulkier 3-rank lines used by the French (and most continental armies). In looking at the British line, one can see how many French commanders would have thought that its apparent fragility would be susceptible to mass column attacks - not so much as it turned out.
Cavalry formations look great in this scale as well as the massed units really help emphasize the space that was required to properly maneuver these large groups of horsemen.
Here are two British cavalry regiments with the one in the foreground in columns of squadrons and the other drawn up in line. |
Above is a French 8-gun battery deployed for action. The depth of the formation is to illustrate the space required to accommodate the supporting ammunition caissons and support wagons. |
So, with a bit of head scratching and eraser nibbling I came up with a series of base shapes that could reflect the various formations commonly used during the period. I estimated I wanted around 30 battalions of infantry each for the French, Austrian, Prussian British and Russians, with a half dozen batteries and around 10 regiments of cavalry as supports. I reasoned that this 'recipe' would give me enough units to reflect a good sized corps per side and not overstress a modest sized table.
After I decided on my basing recipe, my good friend Byron over at Northern Lights Terrain cut me up a schwack of MDF bases to start the process.
Eagle-eyed readers with 15mm collections will see that that frontage of my units are probably not that far off from their own - it's really in the depth that the this scale really differentiates itself.
Is this in true 1:1 scale? No, but its very close. I estimate that these formations are roughly at 1: 1.3 ratio. Not bad!
The Process
The assembly and painting of these bases is a fairly straightforward affair - its definitely more of an assembly line approach than working with larger scales.
I find one of the tricks to tackling small scale projects is getting the basing and colour pallet right. My colour choices I'll talk about below, as to the bases, personally, I like them fairly thick (3mm) as it gives something to grip onto. I also like my bases with rounded corners as it gives the finished stands an almost chit/playing piece look about them. Horses for courses though!
The 3D prints I used for this project makes it very easy to organize and glue down the formations onto the bases, you just mix and match figure strips to the formation you want to do.
They don't look like much, but we'll see what we can make of them. |
This unit will be a standard-sized French battalion, in line formation, five companies wide (the sixth company is assumed to be detached on skirmishing duties).
After the component pieces have been glued down, I apply a layer of fine sand over thinned down PVA on the base. I leave out a small corner section for the unit label and I glue down a steel shim for magnetized markers (more on that later).
Once the sand dries, I prime the base dark brown, and then apply an overspray of grey to help 'lift' lighter colours used later in the process. The groundwork is then painted a chocolate brown, drybrushed up with a mid and light browns and finally ending in a light khaki dusting. I just use cheap craft paint for all this work.
Yes, the base looks a bit wierd at this point, but the next step will set things to right. The base is given several coats of green emulsion from Woodland Scenics. A great product as I find it gives a very nice semi-opaque green effect to the groundwork.
Next is painting the figures themselves. Because of the extremely small scale, I typically use very bright (and very unhistorical) colours so they're easier to see on the tabletop. I simply paint the top half in the 'national' tunic colour - in this case a fairly vibrant blue for the French. I then paint an off-white strip along the bottom and highlight to indicate their trousers.
The light blue is then inked (or washed) with a darker shade. This will sink into the recesses and temporarily darken the overall tone. For the French I use Liquitex Prussian Blue ink (yeah, go figure).
I then highlight with the original colour (light blue in this case) with a few additional spots further lifted with some white mixed in. This gives the figures a bit more depth and aids in their overall visibility.
In order to make the figures better stand out on the base, I outline the formation with a dark brown mixed with a touch of black to create a shadow effect.
Usually the flags are the most fiddly part of the process, but I think the extra time invested really finishes off the base nicely. The French tricolour is fairly easy to do, whereas the British Union Jack can be a bit of a bear!
Aaand that's it for painting the figures. Yes, its very, VERY basic, but I've found that less is more when working with these smaller scales - if you try to paint too much detail it can often muddy the overall effect.
Now, we're almost done: The bases are given a very light scatter of fine flock over thinned PVA. Not too much though, just an impression, going heavy on the flock can often overwhelm the figures.
Finally I touch up the base edge with dark brown, affix a unit label at the bottom corner and magnetize the bottom for safe transport. Done!
The crescent shaped bases are skirmishers. |
An early test game using the figures (no highlighting or flocking yet - slacker). You can see some of the magnetic casualty status markers on a few of the French units. |
I can usually get around 4-6 bases done during an evening's sitting, so roughly a brigade. In preparations for our first game I managed to get 20 battalions of infantry, 4 cavalry regiments and 2 artillery batteries done in around 2 weeks of work - I certainly couldn't have done that in 28mm!
Two regiments of French cavalry in line supporting a brigade of infantry. |
Status Markers
I like using roster sheets to keep tabletop clutter to a minimum and for this project I wanted to take it further by having that ability to denote status right on top of the unit. For example, in GDA units can endure around 8-15 points of damage before breaking. I equated this to three levels/stages of attrition which a unit can be marked: blue for light damage, yellow for medium and red for critical. This way opposing players don't have perfect intelligence on precisely how knocked about an enemy unit is.
So to do this I purchased a pack of magnetic map 'pins' and then spray painted them in the three status colours. I keep them affixed to a thin steel sheet handy for the players to pull from.
During games we simply pick off the markers we need from the steel sheet and place them on the steel square located on the bottom left of each unit. This provides a relatively minimalist approach to marking unit status without having to use dice, counters, etc.
This French brigade is a bit of a bad way. The lovely tree bases are by the very talented Mr. Miles Reidy. |
Storage
Storage is frequently a struggle for many miniature gamers as there just doesn't seem to be enough room to squirrel away all the shiny things we acquire. A great aspect of collecting microscale armies is that their storage and transport is SOOOO much easier than dealing with larger scales.
For this project I found that I could use inexpensive photo scrapbooking containers sourced from one of our local big box craft stores.
The larger containers can carry two of the thinner cases. I've estimated that each nationality could fit in four of the smaller cases, all nestled in two of the larger containers. Since they were available in multiple colours I snagged a pair for most of the nations' livery, red for British, light blue for French, white for Austrians/Spanish, and dark blue for Prussians. I just need to find a set of green cases for the Russians...
This entire project, encompassing five national armies, will fit in 10 cases. This makes it not only very compact to store, but is also fairly straightforward to select, transport and use during games.
Okay, <phew> there you have it. A VERY long post (sorry about that!) of me describing how I spent a good portion of my summer evenings. A bit mental, but good fun.
I plan to do a few more updates on this project in order to cover terrain and a few oddball formations/units. Also, keep an eye out for a Peninsular War scenario that we've developed using these figures; that will be coming up soon as well.
Thanks for dropping in folks. Have a great week!
Next up: Sisters of Battle!
Most impressive and superb mass effect, this scale is so tempting!
ReplyDeleteThanks Phil!
DeleteThe micro scale lunacy continues! All in on every available faction too. Makes one think about use of space and ground, in contrast to large scales.
ReplyDeleteYes, it was fun to see the relative area taken up by each formation, depending on national doctrine. Something you can't usually do in the larger scales.
DeleteBrilliant stuff, Curt!
ReplyDeleteLooking forward to the Sisters of Battle!!?
Thanks Tim! Yes, my Sisters should be ready for their debut in a week or so.
DeleteA fascinating insight into your particular brand of miniatures madness. Smashing work Curt :)
ReplyDeleteHa! Thanks Tamsin.
DeleteVery impressive! A thorough dive into the advantages of this scale. It really looks looks thousands of troops.
ReplyDeleteLooking forward with envy to your SoBs!
Cheers Barks! I hope to have the Girls ready for their debut soon.
DeleteWhat an astonishing post, brilliant stuff Curt. I loved seeing the development of the concept from printing to painting and finally to the table.
ReplyDeleteWhy thank you Michael. I took notes from both you and Sidney on how to describe the project.
DeleteSuperb stuff Curt, If only I was that organised and productive!
ReplyDeleteThanks Ray. It was a very concentrated bout of organizational focus - now I'll be completely useless for the rest of the year...
DeleteHaving played with these on table, I can confirm that the impact and effect is wonderful and really works the charm!
ReplyDeleteThanks Peter, I'm delighted you enjoyed playing with them.
DeleteWonderful post Curt. It really exemplifies how great this hobby can be.
ReplyDeleteThanks Codsticker!
DeleteLooks like your having a lot of fun Curt organizing and building your forces up!
ReplyDeleteChristopher
It has been a bit of a hoot, especially being able to get so much done in a relatively short period of time. Thank goodness for indulgent partners! :)
DeleteAn excellent project, very inspirational
ReplyDeleteThanks Paul, I'm delighted you found it helpful.
DeleteMadness meets method - great work dude!
ReplyDeleteThanks dude - if I could only tap into the same rigour and enthusiasm for my professional life I'd be set. ;)
DeleteI don't see the buttons on the coat tails. Only kidding. They look splendid
ReplyDeleteThat's what your imagination is for. ;) Thanks Khusru!
DeleteNever mind the outcome which is smashing, I thoroughly enjoyed the sneak peak inside the development and build. Thanks for sharing mate!
ReplyDeleteThanks Millsy, you're very kind.
DeleteMy OCD is in love, amazing!
ReplyDeleteHaha, indeed! Thanks Fran.
DeleteWell done my friend! I really can see the appeal of that scale for anything from ancients up to the Franco-Prussian War really. It conveys how such a battle must have looked from afar... admittedly from a rather high mountain top. I always struggle with big formations in 28mm as I simply can‘t get my head around 24 men representing a Batillon/ Brigade whatever. I guess that‘s the Skirmish gamer in me speaking.
ReplyDeleteYou're reading my mind, Nick. I'm thinking of doing much the same for TYW/ECW. I also struggle with 28mm units that are too small to convey what they're trying to represent, but at the same time the hulking units (my Italian Wars pike units for example) take up so much real estate. It's a constant conundrum.
DeleteWell done, brother! Thanks for sharing so many details; I think I'll try your basing technique, as my 2mm lads are on flat green bases ... no charm at all. All the best....Mark Bois
ReplyDeleteThanks Mark. I'm glad all this silliness has provided some small inspiration.
DeleteLovely big sweeping units( in teeny tiny scale!) Conveys unit size and organisations really well too and nice to see the project from start to finish. Looking forward to your Sisters now!
ReplyDeleteBest Iain
Thanks Iain! The Sisters will be up soon. :)
DeleteI know we discussed this earlier, but I wanted to share my praise in public, too. This is an incredible write up, and the best review yet done on my figure range. I'm really impressed with how well you painted and based these up. It puts my own efforts to shame. BTW, this coming weekend I'll get on some of those recommendations for new figures you mentioned, so keep an eye out!
ReplyDeleteI'm delighted you liked the post, Zach. I think what you provide is a terrific resource and and a great alternative for folks who want to get into miniature wargaming without a big investment in time, space or money.
DeleteI very much look forward to your new designs!
Very interesting project and nice effect on these Curt! Great choice with the painting and basing!
ReplyDeleteThanks very much!
DeleteThis is amazing work and has done much to convince me to give 2mm naps a try for myself! I would love to see a painting guide for a the cavalry :)
ReplyDeleteThanks very much Paul. Actually, I've been rethinking on how I want to do the cavalry so keep an eye out for a post coming up.
DeleteWonderful stuff, Curt! This is exactly what I was hoping to find when I Googled "2mm General d'Armee". :)
ReplyDeleteHow do you differentiate between Small, Standard, and Large battalions? Different bases, different company sizes...both? Something else?
Thanks very much David. As to different sizes, yes, I've created units in column, line and square to reflect small, standard and large battalions. In doing this I try to reflect larger company sizes with the prints, but sometimes I have to cheat by using larger strips in order to properly fit them within the bases I've created. I also visually reinforce the varying battalion/regiment sizes by using a subscript 's' or 'l' on their labels to denote those that are smaller-than-standard and larger-than-standard in size. I hope this helps. :)
DeleteSuper helpful, thanks! Can't wait to get to printin'...
DeleteAs a staunch advocate of smaller scale gaming I can only commend you on your project. And my 6mm collection is decisively gigantic next to your armies! Great initiative Curt!
ReplyDeleteThanks Mike, much appreciated!
DeleteAny chance you could PM me for a few fairly simple questions?
ReplyDeletedalebley@gmail.com
For the scale of a one to one ratio of figures to men, which is roughly 1:600, I'm planning to use square bases for the French company (peloton) stands. That way, when in column, the stands can be butted up to each other for normal interval columns, overlapped half way for columns at half interval, and shoved up to touch the figures of the stand to the front for a closed column. The figures print with a 1mm base, which you can edit so I'm putting my figures 1mm from the front edge and leaving a half interval margin to the rear. Mount that on the front half of a metal or MDF base and Bob's your uncle.
ReplyDeleteSounds terrific! I thought of doing separate bases at the company level, but I decided on this path as I liked the look of the larger formations (and they are easy to move/deal with on the playing surface).
DeleteWhat a wonderful post Curt. You’ve gone an outstanding job in explaining the process and the end result looks so good. I look forward to your future write ups as we are also all massive fans of General D’Armee.
ReplyDeleteThank you Carlo! I agree, 'General D'Armee' is a great set of rules.
DeleteI think this is marvellous.
ReplyDeleteI'm taking much the same journey myself at present, and to save time (learn from other people!) I don't spose you'd be able to publish a list of the layouts you used (how many of which of the FM prints to a base of what size) for line, square, column etc?
Thanks very much for the comment. I think with the schematic drawings I did that you can see what numbers I used for prints for the various formations. Typically each print is 20mm long, but some are longer to incorporate the colour party.
DeleteNot sure, but I thought I asked already. Seemingly not!
ReplyDeleteHow many of the "deployed companies" did you use for each Battalion? 6? Or some other rule of thumb?
Apologies, I've been a bit of a laggard keeping up with the blog! I hope my answer above helps.
Delete